Good News!
Maui Bans Plastic Bags
Read the complete story in today’s Honolulu Advertiser. The only bothersome part of this is that the ban won’t take effect until January 11, 2011. The reason given was to give businesses time to use up their plastic bag supplies. Considering the deadly impact that these bags have on our ocean wildlife, perhaps the $200,000 spent annually for a contractor to pick up stray bags blowing around the Central Maui Landfill could be used to buy them up. Or, possibly those merchants still using plastic bags could be enlightened about their danger and they would voluntarily stop handing them out.
They Are Deadly
Ignorant behavior is tolerable until enlightenment occurs; after that it becomes stupidity or selfishness. I can remember a time when cigarette smoking was fashionable and even allowed in hospitals. Everyone had ash trays in their homes, even the rare non-smokers. But once it became known that cigarette smoking and second hand smoke kills, things changed. Imagine a doctor telling a patient, “You have lung cancer and should stop smoking, but go ahead and finish up the carton you have on hand first.”
The yet to be enenlightened will no doubt fight this law as they did the smoking ban. For example, the president of Retail Merchants of Hawaii was quoted as saying, “There is good reason to resist the call for a ban on plastic bags.” She said, “It will have unintended consequences for consumers, including higher costs at the checkout stand as businesses pass along higher shipping costs for bulkier paper bags.” She claimed that it takes seven truckloads of paper bags to carry the same number of plastic bags in a single truckload. I ask, “How much are the lives of our turtles and whales worth?” “Consumer acceptance is another issue,” she said. “It’s going to take quite some time to get everyone to use (reusable bags), and to expect people to leave the house and remember to bring five to six of those bags is just not practical.”
It’s Easy!
I stopped by Foodland on the way home from my walk this morning to buy some fruit juice. I simply purchased a cloth bag. As I did, I shuddered as I watched the checkers stuffing things into plastic bags for the uninformed.
No Need!
Some other justifications offered for continuing the use of plastic were “the ease of carrying leaky plate lunches, dry cleaning, potting soil, hardware items and other goods.” She even said, “People use it to pick up dog poop — what’s your alternative, newspaper? That’s just gross. Plastic bags are very practical in our busy lives.”
I am sensing a big opportunity here for someone to come along with a solution to that problem. Some actually have already. Here’s one bag that feels kind of like plastic, but it is actually made from corn!
Assuming that dog lovers may feel some empathy for other animals, if not the environment itself, I think they will buy in to better solutions once they are made aware of the consequences of the convienece of plastic. There are not very many people fighting for asbestos anymore.
The story said that violators of the bag ban will face administrative fines of up to $1,000. That’s a great deterrant, but let’s hope that the enfocement of the law is done better that the smoking law has been.




August 23rd, 2008 at 11:41 am
I’m with the Retail Merchants on this one. The lives of a few stupid animals that cannot tell the difference between a plastic bag and an anchovy would probably fall prey to a shark or something anyway are not more important than human convenience.
The bible tells us that Man has dominion over the animals. We cannot let the lower animals in the world hold back progress. Plastic bags are one of the greatest inventions ever.
August 23rd, 2008 at 12:23 pm
This is something else.
“Reality Check” is an idiot, and that woman from the retail group is playing politics with her members no doubt. It’s hard to believe that she could be so blind and still hold that position.
August 23rd, 2008 at 1:23 pm
Reality check is rather ignorant! The plastic bag is one of the worst inventions ever! You’ll change your mind soon enough…the landfills are way too crowded and plastic bags almost always end up there. Grow up and do something that will make a difference for your children, my children, and the rest of humanity that will inherit the earth when we’re gone. You talk about the bible, yet you fail to show that you even have the slightest bit of a conscience.
August 24th, 2008 at 3:14 pm
I’m afraid that Reality Check and the Hawaii Retail Merchants have it all wrong here. I’m not sure if it is ignorance or stupidity. There is a difference. I suspect that we have one of each here.
The day will come that plastic bags are seen as what they are; horrible. Convenience isn’t always the answer. We need to think passionately, compassionately, globally, and responsibly.